The Cutest Nutter Butter Turkey Treats for Thanksgiving!

Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and one of my favorite parts of the holiday is getting creative with treats! This year, I can’t wait to share these adorable Nutter Butter Turkey Treats with you—they’re very festive, easy to make, and super ~ perfect for making your Thanksgiving celebration a lot better! 

In addition, you can also check more creative Thanksgiving ideas on my website!

So now, whether you’re looking to add a fun dessert to your table or keep the kids entertained with a hands-on project, I’m 100% sure that these turkey treats will bring smiles all around. 

I’ve put together everything you need to make these delightful Thanksgiving goodies.

Picture of multiple nutter butter turkey treats with the text "Creative Nutter Butter Turkey Treats".

So grab your aprons and make some adorable (and delicious) turkey treats!

This post contains affiliate links. Read my full disclosure.

Turkey Treat Supplies:

How to Make a Nutter Butter Turkey Treat

Making these Nutter Butter Turkey Desserts is so much fun, and trust me, they’ll be a popular treat at your party!

To make these adorable treats, gather some premade brownies, chocolate frosting, Nutter Butter cookies, M&Ms, candy corns, candy eyeballs, and a 3-inch circle cutter (I used a PB&J sandwich cutter).

Nutter butter turkey ingredients

First start by baking a batch of brownies in a lined pan, letting them cool completely before we go into the fun part. 

After they cool and they’re ready, grab a circle cutter and cut out ten brownie rounds—each one will be the base of your turkey.

Cutting circle on the brownie for the nutter butter turkey

Next to keep things looking smooth, flip each brownie upside down, so you’re working with the flat side. Then spread a thin layer of chocolate frosting over it.

Frosting the brownie used for the nutter butter turkey.

Now, take a Nutter Butter and press it right into the center of the brownie—this will be the turkey’s “body.” For the face, just add a dab of frosting to stick on candy eyes and half of an M&M for the “beak.” 

Frosting the brownie used for the nutter butter turkey.

The candy corn feathers come next; press six of them along the top edge of each brownie, fanning them out to look like feathers. And that’s it! Enjoy your adorable (and delicious) little turkey brownie treats.

Picture of a nutter butter turkey

These are not only festive but also such a great way to get into the Thanksgiving spirit, especially if you’re a fan of mixing treats and creativity!

Making Treats in a Fun and Interactive Way

Creating treats doesn’t have to be a solo task—in fact, making it interactive can double the fun! 

Here are a few ways to turn treat-making into a memorable and delicious group activity.

Turn It Into a Family Bonding Activity

Bring the family together by letting everyone join in on the treat-making fun! Kids can help with easy steps, and you’ll enjoy watching their creativity shine.

Add a Little Friendly Competition!

Make it more exciting with a decorating contest! Challenge everyone to create the silliest or most creative treat, and watch as your kitchen fills with laughter and friendly competition.

Set Up a DIY Treat-Decorating Station

A DIY station with all the decorations laid out makes it easy for everyone to build their own treats! It’s like a mini kitchen party where everyone gets to personalize their own creation.

Make It a Friendsgiving or Holiday Party Activity

This isn’t just for family—bring friends into the mix! A treat-making setup can be the perfect interactive activity at any gathering, giving everyone a tasty keepsake they’ll love.

Now, let’s move on to more treats you can try!

More Treats to Try This Thanksgiving!

Looking to try a few more treats this Thanksgiving? Here are some delicious ideas that bring fall flavors and creativity to the table—perfect for sharing with friends and family!

  • These Harvest Indian Corn Cookies are the perfect semi-homemade snack for fall parties or a fun treat to make with the kids. Starting with a classic peanut butter cookie adding a unique, colorful corn motif making it a cute fall cookie. Check out the full tutorial to create these festive cookies!
  • With these 25 Amazing Apple Recipes, you’re bound to find a cozy favorite for the season. From breakfast delights to comforting desserts, these apple recipes remind me of homemade comfort food. I can’t wait to try them all!
  • Take Thanksgiving desserts to the next level with these 27 Thanksgiving Cupcakes. Furthermore, each cupcake is decorated in an adorable way, especially those that feature little turkeys! These cupcakes add charm to the holiday table, and I have to say—I’m obsessed with how cute they are.
  • There’s nothing like indulging in delicious Thanksgiving desserts. These 25+ Thanksgiving Dessert Ideas for the Family make it easy to find a new favorite. From traditional pies to decadent creations, these treats will have everyone’s taste buds celebrating. Every recipe here looks amazing, and I just know they’ll be a hit!
Picture of multiple nutter butter turkey treats with the text "Creative Nutter Butter Turkey Treats".

And to make your treats even more festive, try adding Thanksgiving Treat Bag Toppers! These sweet and personalized printable toppers turn any treat into a thoughtful gift. They add just the right touch for the holiday season.

Picture of a nutter butter turkey
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
No ratings yet

Nutter Butter Turkey Treats

Prep Time5 minutes
15 minutes
Total Time20 minutes
Course: Dessert
Keyword: Thanksgiving Turkey Treats
Servings: 10 turkey treats

Ingredients

  • 1, box 9" x 13" pan premade brownies Follow box baking instructions
  • 1, tub premade chocolate frosting
  • 10 Nutter Butter Cookies
  • 1 package M&Ms
  • 1 package candy corns
  • 20 candy eyeballs
  • 1, 3 inch circle cutter I used a PB&J sandwich cutter

Instructions

  • Line a 9" x 13" baking pan with parchment paper and bake brownies according to the package. Allow to cool completely before removing from the pan.
  • Using a 3 inch circle cutter, cut out 10 circles from the brownies.
  • Flip brownies upside down so you are frosting the bottom – it will be smoother.
  • Frost each brownie with a thin layer of chocolate frosting.
  • Place the nutter butter onto the frosting into the center of the brownie about half way down.
  • Cut 10 red, yellow or orange M&Ms in half.
  • Use a small amount of frosting on the eyes and M&Ms to assemble the turkey’s face.
  • Press 6 candy corns onto each brownie to make the feathers.
  • Enjoy!

Notes

**If making brownies as part of this process, the prep time, assembly time  and total time will need to be adjusted. The time noted above is for brownies that have already been cooked. 

Did you enjoy this recipe? Let me know your thoughts below! 🙂

creative 1
Susan B

Susan B

Hi, I’m Susan! Thanks for stopping by Oh My! Creative. I like to have fun, make fun things…you know, create stuff! I love DIY, decorating and design and like any girl…shopping and lunch!
Susan B

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.